Served as expert on New York law in high-stakes commercial arbitrations involving Fortune 100 companies.
Reviewed/revised briefs in federal and state appeals and motions for leave to appeal to the New York State Court of Appeals.
Participated in moot court sessions for federal and state appeals.
Susan is a former Associate Judge of the New York State Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court. Susan was nominated and confirmed to the court in 2003, and served 12 years on the appellate bench.
In 1995, Susan became Deputy Counsel to Governor George E. Pataki. She was nominated and confirmed to an unexpired term as a judge of the New York State Court of Claims in 1998, and to a full term in 1999, when she was designated Presiding Judge.
During her tenure on the Court of Appeals, Susan authored signed majority opinions addressing novel issues of employment and labor law, including at-will employment and telecommuting; insurance law, including coverage of mental disabilities; conversion of a not-for-profit insurer to a for-profit corporation; tax law, including the constitutionality of New York's “convenience of the employer” test; criminal law; and commercial law, including issues related to liquidated damages, the in pari delicto doctrine, and residential mortgage-backed securities.
She also authored dissents addressing such topics as school funding, consequential damages, and the accrual of the statute of limitations in suits against the State.
Past experience prior to her judicial service includes: Partner, Bond, Schoeneck & King, 1988-1994; In-house counsel, General Electric Co. (1977-1988; Chief Environmental Counsel, nationwide, 1980-1985); Assistant Counsel, State University of New York, 1974-1977. As a practicing attorney prior to her judicial service, Susan counseled clients on commercial matters and transactions and antitrust compliance, and represented clients in grievance arbitrations and discrimination actions. In addition, she supervised environmental litigation and negotiations with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and various state environmental agencies.
Recognition & Leadership
Listed, The Best Lawyers in America, Appellate Practice, 2020
Listed, The Legal 500 United States, Dispute Resolution - Appellate, 2018-2019
Co-Chair, The Chief Judge’s Judicial Advisory Committee on Evidence, 2016-Present
Director, Saratoga Performing Arts Center, 2008-October 2016
Chair, Board of Directors, 2012-October 2016
Trustee of Counsel, December 2016-Present
Board of Directors, School of American Ballet, 2018-Present
Board of Trustees, The Historical Society of the New York Courts, 2010-Present
Board of Trustees, Williamstown Theater Festival, 2015-Present
Member, New York State Bar Association
Member, New York City Bar Association
Member, Rensselaer County Bar Association
Member, Women’s Bar Association of the State of New York
J.D., University of Chicago Law School, 1972
Floyd R. Mechem Prize Scholar
B.A., summa cum laude, Ohio Wesleyan University, 1969
Phi Beta Kappa
News, Insights & Events
Author of numerous articles on legal topics in legal and general interest publications; recent publications in legal journals include Statutory Resolution, 12 Green Bag 2d 85 (2008); Chief Judge John Loughran, 71 Alb L. Rev. 1071 (2009); Exemplary Law Books of 2015: Five Recommendations, 2016 Green Bag Alm. 173 (2016); and Exemplary Legal Writing 2017, Books: Five Recommendations, 2018 Green Bag Alm. 254 (2018).