Skip to main content

Tracking Texas: When Counterclaims Start The Removal Clock

In Bakery LLC v. Naterra International Inc., decided on Sept. 15, Judge Melissa Andrews of the Texas Business Court's Third Division addressed an important timing question: When does the 30-day removal deadline begin if counterclaims — rather than the claims in the original petition — first bring an action within the business court's $5 million amount-in-controversy threshold?

The court held that the deadline began when the counterclaims were filed, not when the defendant had earlier threatened to bring them. The ruling may provide useful guidance for businesses and practitioners assessing removal timing, particularly when a case's potential value changes as the pleadings develop.

Its reasoning, however, turns on the circumstances before the court: The original claims did not meet the jurisdictional threshold, and the counterclaims were the first claims actually pled that brought the total amount in controversy above it.

LINKS

Read “Tracking Texas: When Counterclaims Start The Removal Clock,” authored by Alan Hersh and Sarah Winslow for Law360.

To download a PDF, click the media link below.